Pay off existing subscription fees

Why This Works: Removing Friction and Creating Buzz

Switching costs are a powerful moat for incumbent products. Even if a customer is unhappy, the pain of losing money on a prepaid annual contract is often enough to prevent them from leaving. This play directly bridges that moat with cash or credit. It's a powerful psychological move that tells a customer 'we are so sure you'll be happier here, we're willing to put our money on it'. It targets high-intent, high-value customers who are already looking for a change.

Beyond the individual customer, this is a power-play marketing campaign. It's a direct, public challenge to a competitor that generates industry buzz, social media chatter, and press coverage. It creates a narrative of 'Old, clunky tool vs. New, better tool'. Your existing customers will love the bravado, and your sales team gets a powerful weapon to close deals that were previously stalled by contract lock-in.

Three real examples

The best time to launch this offer is when a competitor announces a price increase, sunsets a popular feature, or gets bad press. This adds urgency and fuel to your fire.

The step-by-step playbook

1. 1

   Step 1: Do the LTV Math

   This tactic is expensive. Before you do anything, calculate your average Customer Lifetime Value (LTV). This will determine your maximum allowable Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) for this offer. For example, if your LTV is $5,000, you might decide you can afford to spend up to $1,000 to acquire a new, high-value customer.

2. 2

   Step 2: Define the Offer and Terms

   Decide exactly what you'll offer. Will you pay in cash (more compelling) or service credits (cheaper and guarantees usage)? What's the maximum buyout amount? Which competitors are eligible? What proof do they need to provide (e.g., a copy of their last invoice)? Write it all down in a clear Terms & Conditions document.

3. 3

   Step 3: Get a Legal Review

   This is non-negotiable. Have your lawyer review your T&Cs and the overall campaign. You need to ensure your offer is legally sound, doesn't make any false claims, and minimizes your risk of fraud or disputes.

4. 4

   Step 4: Create the Landing Page

   Build a dedicated landing page for this offer. It should clearly explain the benefit, how it works, and who is eligible. The most important element is the form where users can apply and upload their proof (e.g., their competitor invoice).

5. 5

   Step 5: Build a Verification Workflow

   How will you handle submissions? Create a clear, internal process. Someone on your team (e.g., in sales ops or marketing) needs to be responsible for reviewing each submission, verifying the invoice, calculating the buyout amount, and coordinating the payout with finance.

6. 6

   Step 6: Launch and Promote Heavily

   Announce your offer everywhere. Publish a blog post, email your newsletter, and post across your social channels. Launch targeted ad campaigns aimed at users of your competitors. Keywords like '[competitor name] alternative' or '[competitor name] pricing' are a goldmine.

7. 7

   Step 7: Empower Your Sales Team

   This is a killer objection-handler for your sales reps. Give them a one-pager on how the offer works and train them to use it when a prospect says, 'I'd love to switch, but I'm stuck in an annual contract.' It turns a 'no' into a 'yes'.

8. 8

   Step 8: Track Your ROI

   Measure everything. Track how many people sign up through this offer, the total cost, and the CAC per customer. Most importantly, use a tool like June.so to track the LTV of this specific cohort to confirm that your initial math was right and the investment is paying off.

Copy-Paste Sales Outreach Template

Use this email for targeted outreach to high-value prospects you know are using a key competitor. It's direct, confident, and gets straight to the point.

Subject: Stuck in your {Competitor} contract?

Hi {FirstName},

My name is {YourName} from {YourProduct}. I'm reaching out because many companies in the {Industry} space switch from {Competitor} to us to get {Benefit1} and {Benefit2}.

Often, the only thing stopping them is a prepaid annual contract.

We've decided to remove that barrier. If you're stuck in a contract with {Competitor}, we will pay off the remainder of your term when you switch to {YourProduct}. We're that confident you'll get more value with us.

No strings attached. You can read the full details of our offer here: {LandingPageLink}

Worth a look?

Best,
{YourName}

Key Questions to Answer First

• Is our LTV high enough to justify paying up to 12 months of a competitor's fees?
• Which 1-3 specific competitors should we target for maximum impact?
• Should we offer cash/prepaid card or service credit? Credit is cheaper, but cash is a much stronger marketing claim.
• What is the absolute maximum dollar amount we will pay out per new customer?
• Do we have the operational staff to verify invoices and process payments quickly and without errors?

The most critical question is financial. If your LTV-to-CAC ratio doesn't work, the tactic is a non-starter. Also, focus on how to prevent fraud--require a full invoice and consider only paying out after the user has successfully onboarded.

Recommended tools

Prices are indicative and change - check the vendor before buying.

Do it faster with AI Prompts

Mistakes that kill this play

• ×Not doing the math. You must know your LTV and set a maximum CAC for this offer, or you will lose money.
• ×Creating a slow, complicated claims process. This is your new customer's first experience with you. If it's painful, they will churn.
• ×Using vague T&Cs. Ambiguity leads to disputes. Be crystal clear about who is eligible, what they get, and how they get it.
• ×Not marketing the offer. A brilliant offer nobody hears about is worthless. You need to run ads and empower your sales team to promote it.
• ×Failing to prevent fraud. Require an actual invoice from the competitor, not just a screenshot or a number typed in a box.
• ×Not having a retention strategy. Acquiring these expensive users is pointless if you can't keep them. Ensure your onboarding and product experience is ready to deliver on your promise.

Your First 7-Day Sprint

• Day 1: Finalize the financial model. Determine max payout amount based on LTV. Choose the top 1-2 competitors you will target.
• Day 2: Draft the full Terms & Conditions. Define eligibility, proof required, and payout method. Send the draft to your lawyer for review.
• Day 3: Build the landing page. Write the copy (use Jasper.ai) and build the application form (use Tally.so) for users to upload their invoices.
• Day 4: Create the promotional assets. Write the announcement blog post, the email for your list, and the ad copy for paid campaigns.
• Day 5: Train your team. Hold a short meeting with your sales and support teams. Walk them through the offer and give them a written FAQ.
• Day 6: Launch the campaign. Publish the landing page, send the announcement email, and activate your ad campaigns targeting competitor keywords.
• Day 7: Monitor initial applications. Review the first few submissions to ensure your verification and payout process is smooth. Fix any early kinks.

More Level 4 hacks